Really, weāre going to do this? OK:
On the contrary it does matter who does the research. A creationist who does āresearchā on evolution by studying the bible brings zero value to the field. This Russian announcement is from someone who is the euivalent in biology of creationism, as he believes in a distinct āRussian genomeā - this has as little value as the Lysenkoism that destroyed Soviet genetic research for decades.
āThe field could also do with some new ideas, and the Russians may identify different approaches that havenāt been explored yet.ā
The Russians will identify no approaches, let alone different ones, as this proposal is just empty words with zero behind it. Would you also say that āwe could do with some different sources of moneyā in response to an article about a Nigerian Prince scam email? It makes as little sense. Nobody would even dignify either with any speculation as to the funds from the email scam or results from this āresearchā that exists only as a press release.
āNo doubt they (like others) will run into plenty of dead-ends; but the big breakthroughs will only come from exloring new avenues rather than just from perfecting things like rapamycin and its analogues.ā
Clearly - with your own words - you are in fact postulating that ātheyā (Russians) might run into dead ends - but that clearly, CLEARLY assumes that they will do research, otherwise how can they run into dead ends. But there will be no research. You are only ASSUMING there will be research. There wonāt. The Nigerian Prince is not sending money, and in fact there is no Nigerian Prince. There is not and will not be any research, dead end or otherwise as a result of this press release.
āI just hope they are taking it seriously.ā Would you also hope the Nigerian Prince has funds to send you? This is about as reasonable a hope. There is ZERO chance that anyone in Russia is taking this seriously. The sole reality of this project is as a press release, or Nigerian email scam.
āIf you believe the article, the aspiration to extend Russianās lifespans isnāt yet backed up with the massive funding that such an undertaking will need.ā
The āaspirationā isnāt āyetā backed up, in the same way the Nigerian Princes email is not āyetā backed by millions of dollars about to flow to your bank account. There is no āyetā. There is only ālol, neverā. The very use of the word āyetā assumes there is a possibility that there will be funding for this wild project. There is no such possibility - just as there is no possibility that the Nigerian Prince has millions for you⦠in fact, the Nigerian Prince doesnāt exist, just as this project doesnāt exist except as an email in one case and an empty press release in the other.
And now Iām done with this topic, because just as in the case of the Nigerian Prince scam emails, some folks will always, always believe in that reality no matter what anyone else says. Good luck with the Russian cure for aging.