https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2024.114496

Study shows the molecular basis of the ATP-citrate lyase (ACLY)-mediated senescence-associated secretory phenotype in senescent cells via the pro-inflammatory enhancer remodeling.

Bempedoic acid acts by inhibiting adenosine triphosphate-citrate lyase (ACL) and consequently cholesterol biosynthesis, leading to increased expression of LDL receptors and increasing low-density lipoproteins (LDL-C) plasma clearence.

image

5 Likes

@John_Hemming Thoughts on this?

2 Likes

I wouldn’t do it myself. ACLY is pretty essential for all cellular function. Switching it off may stop/reduce SASP, but it would reduce lots of other things.

Limitations of the study

As a limitation of this in vivo study, under the inhibitions of ACLY and BRD4, we have apparently observed little morphological improvement in the aged tissues of the kidney and liver (Figures S5C–S5E), suggesting that these treatments could not reverse or remove already established aging lesions in the present experimental setting. In contrast, the serum levels of ALT/AST enzymes in the aged mice have evidently reached the same levels as those in young mice (Figure 6E), indicating the functional improvement in these tissues. Because the STAT1-mediated IFN response was strongly repressed in the genome-wide transcriptome by inhibiting the ACLY-BRD4 axis (Figures 6G–6I), there is the high possibility that these inhibitors can halt the progression of aging lesions or recover organic changes with long-term treatment. Thus, we expect that the inhibitions of ACLY and BRD4 can mitigate tissue damage and prevent the progression of pathogenic aging without eliminating SnCs.

This study employed the chemical compounds DCV and JQ1 to inhibit ACLY and BRD4, respectively, in vivo. However, the effect of these inhibitors on animal lifespan and health span has not been assessed. Since these inhibitors do not specifically target SnCs, the SnC-specific inhibition of the ACLY-BRD4 axis would be necessary to understand the precise role of this pathway in in vivo contexts.

3 Likes

@John_Hemming Does this mean that bempedoic acid might be worse for longevity than other ways to modulate down LDl-C/Apo B?

1 Like

I would have to spend some time reading up on this to comment.

1 Like

I have been taking bempedoic acid for almost a year, it does cause a significant reduction in LDL-C levels. I have encountered no detectable adverse side effects in my blood markers.
It has produced no adverse subjective side effects, unlike the statins that I have used. I will continue to take bempedoic acid. It has no downsides for most people.

“CLEAR Harmony Trial:
Study: The CLEAR Harmony trial evaluated the safety and efficacy of bempedoic acid in patients with hypercholesterolemia. The study found significant reductions in LDL-C levels and a favorable safety profile.
CLEAR Wisdom Trial:
Study: The CLEAR Wisdom trial assessed the efficacy of bempedoic acid in patients with atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD) or heterozygous familial hypercholesterolemia (HeFH). The results showed significant LDL-C reductions and an acceptable safety profile.
Summary of Key Points
Mechanism of Action: Bempedoic acid inhibits ATP-citrate lyase (ACL), reducing cholesterol production in the liver and lowering LDL-C levels.
Uses: It is used to treat hypercholesterolemia, particularly in patients who are statin-intolerant or unable to achieve cholesterol goals with statins alone.
Efficacy: Clinical trials have shown significant LDL-C reductions, especially when used in combination with other lipid-lowering therapies.”

6 Likes

@desertshores No concerns or thoughts re @John_Hemming ’s point here:

1 Like

In a word “no”. IMO: There is no compelling evidence that bempedoic acid is anything but beneficial.
Based on current evidence I will continue taking bempedoic acid.

As far as I can tell, you can find a reason not to take any supplements.

9 Likes

Bempedoic Acid: inhibits ACLY in the liver, reducing the production of acetyl-CoA, a precursor for cholesterol and fatty acid synthesis. The liver-specific action of bempedoic acid minimizes systemic side effects, making it a safer option for long-term use compared to other cholesterol-lowering drugs.

There’s a study, showing that ACLY plays a role in promoting pro-inflammatory SASP. If bempedoic acid similarly reduces ACLY activity in senescent cells, it might help mitigate age-related inflammation? However, its primary action is in the liver, so this effect may be limited.

Inhibition of ACLY might affect the production of acetyl-CoA, potentially impacting energy metabolism and mitochondrial function. However I presume, the liver’s adaptability and the specific targeting by bempedoic acid may mitigate systemic metabolic disruptions.

Long-term inhibition of ACLY in the liver could theoretically impair the liver’s capacity to synthesize essential lipids, although clinical trials have not shown significant adverse effects related to liver function.

→ BAs specific action in the liver, combined with the absence of significant adverse effects in clinical trials, suggests that bempedoic acid is unlikely to negatively impact aging.

For sure, further research is needed to fully understand the long-term effects of ACLY inhibition in liver on aging and longevity.

I am personally on my own trial :slight_smile: with 90mg BA + 5mg ezetimibe daily.

7 Likes

My own view is that if BA only inhibits ACLY in the liver then the harm from it will be limited. In practice it is possible to create acetyl-CoA from acetate via ACSS2. Also inhibition is not normally total.

I don’t, however, personally think that is the best step in the pathway to inhibit. I wonder also to what extent it limits gene expression in the liver. That, however, will only be clear over a number of years.

Hence I don’t really have a good answer (yes or no) on this. I personally don’t take BA and don’t intend to.

2 Likes

Good point. Bempedoic acid itself is an inactive prodrug. It requires conversion to its active form by very-long-chain acyl-CoA synthetase (ACSVL1) ACSVL1 is predominantly expressed in the liver, which means that the activation of bempedoic acid occurs mainly in hepatic tissues. The presence of ACSVL1 in other tissues is minimal enough that it doesn’t lead to significant inhibition of ACLY outside the liver, thus minimizing potential systemic side effects.

Here is relevant study: Lipogenesis inhibitors: therapeutic opportunities and challenges:

ACLY inhibition, which lowers acetyl-CoA, may affect the acetylation profile of many different histones, potentially having a wide array of differential effects on gene expression profiles and epigenetic programming275. Thus, it is pivotal to consider the effects of metabolic intermediates when developing DNL inhibitors as a therapeutic approach.

Inhibition of ACLY can also be bypassed in some cancer cells278 and in the liver of mice fed a high-fructose diet45 through upregulation of ACSS2. These data suggest that depending on the nutritional context and cell types involved, for DNL inhibitors to be highly effective it may be necessary to also target compensatory mechanisms. For example, might it be important for people being treated with an ACLY inhibitor to limit their alcohol and fructose intake to maximize effects?

Despite these compelling data in preclinical models, data generated in clinical settings with respect to ACLY inhibition for LDL lowering173,181,182, ACC inhibitors for NASH48,72,205,224 and FAS inhibition for cancer264 suggest that the degree of DNL inhibition achieved may be sufficient to overcome any compensatory pathways. However, further studies investigating this will be important.

Hmmm… food for thoughts!

6 Likes

A few additional thoughts on this interesting topic.

In the CLEAR Outcomes and CLEAR Harmony trials, patients treated with BP experienced significant reductions in hsCRP. In the CLEAR Wisdom trial, BP lowered hsCRP by 20-25%. The reduction was independent LDL lowering, suggesting broad anti-inflammatory action.

If BP reduces SASP-related inflammation by targeting ACLY, it could in theory also reduce the levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines associated with senescent cells, such as IL-1β, IL-6, and TNF-alpha.

Since the likely alternative to BP for many will be a statin, it may be relevant to note that some research has suggested that residual inflammatory risk (i.e., ongoing inflammation despite LDL-C lowering) remains a concern with statin therapy. While BP’s effects on inflammation-driven longevity mechanisms (like SASP) are speculative, BP’s ability to reduce hsCRP and LDL-C suggests it could address both cholesterol-driven and inflammation-driven cardiovascular risks.

I am currently taking 180 mg. of BP daily. Soon, I’m going to take a comprehensive look at all relevant serum metrics. I’ll report back on my N=1 observations. So far, I can report no detectable side effects.

10 Likes

BP = Bempedoic Acid?

1 Like

:+1: (plus the required characters).

2 Likes

Thanks @Barnabas , great thread! Led me to investigate more as this looks like a critical process to understand. And it is directly related to @John_Hemming 's focus on the citrate cycle, ACLY and acetyl-CoA. From the study in the lead-off post:

Citrate metabolism controls the senescent microenvironment via the remodeling
of pro-inflammatory enhancers

Here, we show that ATP-citrate lyase (ACLY), a key enzyme in acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA) synthesis, is essential for the pro-inflammatory SASP, independent of persistent growth arrest in senescent cells. Citrate-derived acetyl-CoA facilitates the action of SASP gene enhancers. ACLY-dependent de novo enhancers augment the recruitment of the chromatin reader BRD4, which causes SASP activation. Consistently, specific inhibitions of the ACLY-BRD4 axis suppress the STAT1-mediated interferon response, creating the pro-inflammatory microenvironment in senescent cells and tissues. Our results demonstrate that ACLY-dependent citrate metabolism represents a selective target for controlling SASP designed to promote healthy aging.

I started my search here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATP_citrate_synthase

Pharmacology

The **ATP citrate lyase (ACLY)**enzyme’s action can be inhibited by the coenzyme A-conjugate of bempedoic acid, a compound which lowers LDL cholesterol in humans.[14] The drug was approved by the Food and Drug Administration in February 2020 for use in the United States.

And the paper posted by @SilentWatcher is quite interesting and deserves further quotes - it’s a very long paper.

Abstract

Fatty acids are essential for survival, acting as bioenergetic substrates, structural components and signalling molecules. Given their vital role, cells have evolved mechanisms to generate fatty acids from alternative carbon sources, through a process known as de novo lipogenesis (DNL). Despite the importance of DNL, aberrant upregulation is associated with a wide variety of pathologies. Inhibiting core enzymes of DNL, including citrate/isocitrate carrier (CIC), ATP-citrate lyase (ACLY), acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC) and fatty acid synthase (FAS), represents an attractive therapeutic strategy. Despite challenges related to efficacy, selectivity and safety, several new classes of synthetic DNL inhibitors have entered clinical-stage development and may become the foundation for a new class of therapeutics.

Introduction

Fatty acids are essential for cell survival as they serve as key structural components of cell membranes and important signalling molecules. Fatty acids are also the most calorically dense form of energy storage with the conversion of excess glucose into fatty acids protecting against glucotoxicity and providing a much larger energy reserve than glycogen for times of nutrient scarcity. Given the vital roles of fatty acids, cells have evolved mechanisms to maintain them at adequate levels. This includes mechanisms to take up exogenous fatty acids but also to generate fatty acids from alternative carbon sources through a series of enzymatic reactions, a process highly conserved across phyla known as de novo lipogenesis (DNL)1.

DNL is initiated when excess substrate availability, relative to cellular energy demands, leads to increases in mitochondrial citrate, which is exported from mitochondria into the cytosol by the mitochondrial citrate/isocitrate carrier (CIC; also known as CTP and SLC25A1) (Fig. 1). This cytosolic citrate is then converted into fatty acids by a series of biosynthetic reactions catalysed by ATP-citrate lyase (ACLY), acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC; also known as ACACA) and fatty acid synthase (FAS; also known as FASN). The expression of these enzymes differs across tissues and stages of development (for example, proliferation or quiescence). Expression and activity are also acutely and chronically regulated through transcriptional control and post-translational modifications that are linked to nutritional status (for example, fasting and feeding) and substrate availability (for example, fatty acids suppress DNL).

Although DNL is vital to maintain whole-body and cellular homeostasis, chronic elevations are associated with the development of a broad spectrum of diseases and disorders including cardiovascular disease (CVD)2,3, nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD)4,5, type 2 diabetes (T2D)5,6, numerous cancers7,8, viral infections9,10, autoimmune diseases11,12, acne vulgaris13, neurodegeneration14 and ageing15. This suggests that pharmacological inhibition may be beneficial across multiple disease areas (Box 2; Supplementary Fig. 1). Several natural products have been identified as inhibitors of DNL and these have been adopted as a cornerstone for the development of synthetic inhibitors that display improved bioavailability, efficacy and specificity.

Bempedoic acid and BMS-303141, two of the better-characterized ACLY inhibitors, have strengthened a potential connection between weight loss and ACLY, with both reducing body weight gain and adiposity independently of changes in food intake in preclinical models160,166,167,172. Importantly, recent evidence has emerged from pooled analyses of clinical trials that bempedoic acid elicits modest weight loss in humans173. Studies examining the potential mechanisms by which ACLY inhibitors exert weight loss are warranted.

Bempedoic acid also reduced hepatic triglycerides and markers of inflammation in Ldlr−/− mice fed a diet high in fat and cholesterol. Importantly, the liver lipid-lowering effects of bempedoic acid are independent of liver AMPK activation167. In multiple mouse models, bempedoic acid also reduced fasting glucose, fasting insulin and glucose intolerance, suggesting improvements in insulin sensitivity172. Importantly, these effects appear to be translated to humans, as a meta-analysis of randomized trials suggests that bempedoic acid reduces new incidence or worsening of diabetes176. Whether bempedoic acid is effective at reversing NASH and fibrosis remains to be determined.

Bempedoic acid also suppresses hepatic cholesterol and fatty acid biosynthesis172 and its hypolipidaemic actions have been demonstrated in hyperlipidaemic hamsters172, obese Zucker rats166 and in mice deficient for ApoE167 or the LDL receptor179 in which atherosclerosis is also reduced. In humans, bempedoic acid promotes dose-dependent LDL-cholesterol lowering effects as monotherapy, and when combined with a statin or ezetimibe180. Unlike rodents, in which bempedoic acid has a profound effect in reducing both plasma triglycerides and cholesterol, the primary effect of bempedoic acid in humans appears to be a reduction in plasma LDL-cholesterol180. The lack of effect on plasma triglycerides may potentially be due to lower liver DNL in humans compared with rodents. In addition to lowering LDL-cholesterol, bempedoic acid also reduces several plasma markers associated with atherosclerotic CVD such as total cholesterol, non-HDL cholesterol, plasma apoB, LDL particle numbers and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein

In the past 50 years tremendous progress has been made in understanding the biochemical mechanisms and physiological significance of DNL in regulating cellular metabolism and whole-body energy homeostasis. Important steps along the way have included biochemical identification of the key metabolic intermediates in the conversion of glucose to fatty acids, the molecular cloning of the key enzymes regulating the process and the discovery of crucial allosteric and covalent mechanisms that regulate flux through the pathway. Subsequent studies in genetically modified mice revealed the physiological role of DNL, broadening our understanding of the complex connections that exist between multiple cellular processes and tissues well beyond the simple storage of excess calories in adipose tissue. Meanwhile, advances in structural biology laid the foundation for the molecular underpinnings by which natural products and new-generation small molecules inhibited enzyme activity. Although these compounds vary in their molecular target, chemical structure and physicochemical properties, the common action in which DNL is inhibited supports the notion that it is beneficial for the prevention and treatment of a broad spectrum of diseases.

Lastly, ACLY inhibition, which lowers acetyl-CoA, may affect the acetylation profile of many different histones, potentially having a wide array of differential effects on gene expression profiles and epigenetic programming. Thus, it is pivotal to consider the effects of metabolic intermediates when developing DNL inhibitors as a therapeutic approach. Similarly, genetic inhibition of ACLY in muscle and adipose tissue results in muscle weakness and lipodystrophy, respectively, but has been avoided by the development of the liver-targeted prodrug bempedoic acid. Liver-specific inhibition of DNL may also be helpful to avoid the potential detrimental effect of adipose tissue DNL inhibition on whole-body insulin sensitivity, given that adipose tissue DNL directly correlates with insulin sensitivity.

Ultimately, whether DNL inhibitors are safe and effective enough to be used as a monotherapy or will be used in combination with other therapies to enhance efficacy or offset liabilities, as has been proposed for ACC inhibitors in NASH, will depend on clinical trial results. In this regard, findings with the ACLY inhibitor bempedoic acid are encouraging as they suggest that chronic inhibition of DNL in the liver is safe when used alone or with other standards of care. Whether DNL inhibitors that target other cell types and organ systems become widely adopted as a cornerstone for treating other disease indications beyond CVD and NASH remains to be determined.

4 Likes

Compelling answers to these questions would likely be arrived at only via full experimental designs with severe incidents and death as endpoints. Given that such is not possible for several reasons, there is enough data out there for a form of large N, multi-national cross-sequential hybrid design.

1 Like

This is a reason, why I am thinking about cycling of bempedoic acid. Taking currently 90mg BA and 5mg ezetimibe daily. Plan to introduce 2-3 months “vacation” - introducing some low dose statin like rosuvastatin or pitavastatin (keeping ezetimibe) and look at liver enzymes… I am not very much convinced about long term safety (->liver) of BA in light of a.m. study.

5 Likes

How much have you been able to lower LDL-C or APOB levels with the 90 mg dose?

5 Likes

Yes an important point on that, no heavy workouts where you have aching sore muscles in the days before getting transaminases measured (AST/ALT). The reason why is release of myoglobin from your muscles, and a bump up in your CK (if >5000 then = mild rhabdomyolysis). It isn’t unusual for conditions where you have sore muscles for many days to pump you up to 1000-5000 on your CK.

Why this matters, is that this same release pretty consistently also releases some AST/ALT from muscles, so those transaminases aren’t only there in your liver. Typically, you’ll get 5-10% of the CK level added to your AST, and 2-5% for ALT.

So if you had a CK of 2000, you might bump your AST by 100-200 in addition to what is coming from your liver, and 40-100 for your ALT.

8 Likes